Are AI notetakers helping or hurting your meetings?
It feels like every other week a new AI tool pops up, promising to “make meetings effortless, saving you hundreds of hours.” One of the hottest right now is AI notetakers. Tools that join your Zoom, Teams, or Google Meet, quietly record the call, and then generate a transcript and summary for you.
In theory, it sounds amazing. No more frantic typing. No more “Wait. What did they say about that deadline/that feature request?” You can actually sit back and be present.
I was a rabid fan when I started using them. But, like most shiny new AI helpers, it’s not all upside.
The positives
You’ll never miss a detail again
Having a transcript is great if someone misses a meeting or if you just want to check back on who agreed to what. From an accountability standpoint, that is a huge plus.
Freedom to actually listen
Instead of scribbling notes, you can make eye contact the entire time and really focus on the conversation, knowing the AI will capture it all.
Great for remote teams
When your teammates are spread across time zones, having a neat summary waiting in Slack or email can keep everyone aligned without another meeting.
So far so good.
Where it gets messy
People clam up
The moment you tell a customer, “By the way, we’re recording this,” the tone often changes. They’re less likely to be brutally honest about what isn’t working. That’s obviously a problem if you actually want the truth.
Things become performative
The opposite can also happen: instead of clamming up, people sometimes go into “stage mode” when they know they’re being recorded. They perform instead of just talking, which makes the whole meeting feel less authentic.
You stop taking your own notes
There’s something about writing things down that makes your brain hold onto them better. If you just rely on AI, you’re outsourcing not just the notes but your memory. I can certainly attest to that. I remember more details from meetings I had pre-notetaker compared to the ones where I had it running.
You over-rely on other people’s discussions
If you care about delivering the right products and services to your customers, you can’t just lurk in transcripts of meetings you weren’t in. You need to talk to customers yourself frequently (here’s more on the subject). You know best what insights you want, and you’ll never get the same clarity secondhand.
Coaching gets robotic
It’s tempting to let AI summaries or call insights do the work of coaching sales reps and customer success managers. But AI can’t detect subtle hesitations, awkward silences, or emotional tones that matter in human relationships. Leaders still need to guide and mentor, especially since AI doesn’t have the same context as you when it comes to organizational history, challenges, or your relationship with a customer.
AI can’t read the room
Yes, it knows what was said. But it has no clue how it was said. That subtle sarcasm? Gone. The change in tone? Undetected. The tension you felt when someone crossed their arms? Can’t be found in the notes.
Not every meeting needs a transcript
Sometimes it’s overkill. Recording everything can make people feel like they’re under surveillance. And honestly, it can be a massive distraction. Plus, it’s a time sink when people start digging through meetings they weren’t even in just out of curiosity.
Privacy risks are real
You’re storing transcripts of strategy calls, customer complaints, even HR issues. Those are sensitive topics, and they need to be treated with care, or it could come back to bite you.
Is there a middle ground?
To be clear, I’m not anti-AI notetaker. They can be lifesavers in the right situation. But like most tools, the value depends on how you use them.
Ask yourself:
- Do we really need this meeting recorded?
- Will it make people less likely to share openly?
- Am I letting AI make me lazy?
If the answer to any of those is “yes,” maybe leave the bot out of it.
AI notetakers are like that super-organized friend who always remembers the details. They’re great to have around, but you don’t want to rely on them so much that you stop paying attention yourself.
Meetings are, at their core, about humans connecting problem-solving, and helping each other . Let’s not lose that just because a bot can spit out bullet points.
What about you? Do you find that AI-notetakers help or hurt your meetings?